The Philadelphia Phillies are gearing up for the 2025 season with a pivotal decision looming over the catcher position. J.T. Realmuto, the star catcher, is entering the final year of his contract, and the organization has yet to engage in discussions regarding an extension. This situation places Realmuto in a unique position where the team might maximize his usage this season, considering his potential departure after his age-35 season. However, concerns about Realmuto's performance have arisen, as his play has declined since his exceptional 2022 season, where he earned both Gold Glove and Silver Slugger honors.
To manage this delicate balance, the Phillies are strategizing to reduce Realmuto's playing time in hopes of preserving his effectiveness for the latter part of the season and the playoffs. This plan hinges heavily on the performance of the backup catcher, a role that has become increasingly significant. Currently, the projected starter remains Realmuto, with Rafael Marchan anticipated to take on the backup role. The team is likely to send fan favorite Garrett Stubbs to Triple-A due to his remaining minor league option, while Marchan, once a promising prospect, looks to reclaim his place after battling injuries.
Marchan's recent performance, where he showcased his potential in a limited stint last season, positions him as a viable backup. However, if he struggles or faces injury setbacks, Stubbs could be recalled, risking Marchan's future with the team. The Phillies are also experimenting with additional options, having acquired Paul McIntosh and signed Payton Henry to a minor league deal. As the season approaches, the dynamics of the catcher position are set to evolve, especially if Marchan steps up as the backup on Opening Day, which could significantly impact the team's overall performance.
