The Philadelphia Phillies showcased a formidable roster in 2024, achieving 95 wins and clinching the National League East title for the first time since 2011. Despite their regular season success, their postseason was cut short by the New York Mets, raising questions about manager Rob Thomson's decision-making.

Thomson's reliance on struggling pitcher Craig Kimbrel in critical moments backfired, leading to pivotal losses in the National League Championship Series and Division Series. Critics argue that his managerial choices contributed significantly to the team's playoff exits, prompting discussions about potential replacements who could better utilize the team's analytic strengths.