The fantasy baseball shortstop landscape in 2025 is loaded with both undervalued and overvalued players, creating a rich terrain for fantasy enthusiasts. Names like Bobby Witt Jr. and Francisco Lindor are commanding top draft slots, while players like Ezequiel Tovar and Bo Bichette present intriguing value options. Tovar, despite his high whiff rate, showcased potential with a successful 2024 season, making him a sleeper pick at ADP 160. Conversely, Bichette's injury-riddled past year at 131.3 ADP could yield a bounce-back opportunity. Then there’s Willy Adames, signed by the Giants, who may be overvalued due to his new pitcher-friendly environment. A comprehensive look reveals that while some shortstops are primed for breakout seasons, others may not live up to their lofty draft positions.