As fantasy baseball draft season approaches, targeting the right starting pitchers will be crucial for success. Four American League pitchers stand out based on performance metrics and potential value relative to their Average Draft Position (ADP). Bryan Woo of the Seattle Mariners, with an impressive 2024 season featuring a 2.89 ERA, is a top pick, thanks to his strikeout ability and the pitcher-friendly T-Mobile Park. Joe Ryan of the Minnesota Twins has shown consistent improvement and a solid strikeout rate, making him a strong candidate if he can maintain health. Spencer Arrighetti from the Houston Astros impressed during his rookie season, ranking well in strikeouts and extension metrics, which can enhance his performance in 2025. Lastly, Gavin Williams of the Cleveland Guardians represents a high-upside pick despite a disappointing 2024, with potential for a bounce-back season based on his velocity and extension metrics.