With Vladimir Guerrero Jr. securing his future with the Toronto Blue Jays, all eyes are now on Bo Bichette. General Manager Ross Atkins has expressed a desire to keep both players together, especially with a potentially weak upcoming free-agent class. The challenge lies in determining Bichette's market value for an extension, which is assessed using the Wins Above Replacement (WAR) metric. A player like Bichette, who has maintained around 4-5 WAR, could theoretically command a salary ranging from $34 million annually based on current market trends.

Recent contracts for top shortstops provide a framework for what Bichette might expect. High-profile deals like those of Francisco Lindor and Fernando Tatis Jr. demonstrate the lucrative nature of the position. However, if Bichette's value falls outside the top tier, mid-range contracts such as those signed by Willy Adames or Trevor Story could serve as more realistic benchmarks. As the season progresses, discussions surrounding Bichette's future will intensify, especially given the Jays' potential salary flexibility following the 2026 season.