Kyle Finnegan, 33, made his first career All-Star appearance in 2024 and had a strong start to the season with a 1.98 ERA and 0.936 WHIP through June 3. However, he struggled down the stretch, posting a 5.93 ERA and 1.866 WHIP in the latter part of the season. He finished with a 3.68 ERA, 1.335 WHIP, and converted 38 of his 43 save opportunities, while making at least 65 appearances in each of the last four seasons. Since his MLB debut in 2020, only one National League pitcher has appeared in more games than him.

Kyle Finnegan, the Nationals' closer for the past two seasons and an All-Star in 2024, was non-tendered after a strong performance in previous years. Despite throwing at least 60 innings each of the last four seasons, his projected 2025 salary of around $9 million was deemed too high for a 33-year-old reliever with middling underlying stats. The Nationals opted to release him rather than pursue a trade.

Kyle Finnegan is seen as a potential target for the Phillies as they seek a closer. He posted a 3.68 ERA last season, but his xERA of 4.34 suggests he may have benefited from some luck. While he possesses solid velocity, he lacks standout skills that would justify the Phillies giving up significant assets like Castellanos and Caba for just one season of his services. Although he is a capable reliever, there are concerns that the Phillies could find better options in free agency.

Kyle Finnegan is positioned as a valuable trade asset for the Nationals, capable of filling an immediate need in the Phillies' bullpen. His departure would allow Washington to pursue a trade for Nick Castellanos, a proven power hitter, while also potentially receiving cash and a prospect in return. Finnegan's role as a late-inning relief pitcher makes him an appealing option for Philadelphia, which is looking to strengthen its roster after an early playoff exit.

Kyle Finnegan has established himself as one of the best relievers in baseball since his debut in 2020, boasting a 3.56 ERA and a strong save record. Despite his success, he has struggled in the second half of the season over the past two years, which could affect his trade value. The Nationals are likely to retain him throughout the 2025 season unless he has an exceptional first half that compels the front office to consider trading him. Finnegan is set to enter a contract year, and the team hopes he can replicate his All-Star form, potentially leading to a decision on his future with the franchise.