Ryan Lindgren's return to the Rangers has coincided with a decline in the team's defensive performance, raising concerns about his current effectiveness. Once a reliable top-pair defenseman, he has struggled against teams that apply pressure, showing signs of decline reminiscent of past players who faced similar fates. Despite having better season-long numbers than Victor Mancini, Lindgren's struggles have led to questions about his role and minutes on the ice. His presence has disrupted previously successful defensive pairings, and there are calls for the coaching staff to reconsider his position and impact on the team's overall performance.