Fantasy baseball in 2025 is heavily influenced by first base options, with multiple high ADPs making the position competitive. Among the top names, Spencer Steer of the Cincinnati Reds and Paul Goldschmidt of the New York Yankees raise concerns due to their declining stats. Steer's disappointing .225 average and Goldschmidt's drop to .245 suggest fantasy managers may be better off looking elsewhere. Triston Casas' injury struggles further complicate matters, while Josh Naylor's RBI output is appealing but comes with risks. There are solid alternatives available at lower ADPs, making it essential to reassess investments in these first basemen.