Orlando Arcia has been a steady presence at shortstop for the Braves, but his performance has left room for potential change as the team explores options, including the newly acquired Christian Cairo.

Orlando Arcia's defensive skills are highlighted as a key asset for the Braves, but his offensive performance, particularly with runners in scoring position, raises concerns. In fact, Arenado outperformed Arcia in critical hitting scenarios, driving in more runs than Arcia did overall.

Orlando Arcia had a strong showing as an All-Star for the Braves in 2023, hitting 17 home runs and driving in 65 runs. However, his offensive production declined in 2024, with a significant drop in batting average, on-base percentage, and slugging percentage, leading to concerns about his consistency. Despite being only 30 years old and due for a bounce-back season, the Braves may seek an upgrade at shortstop, making Arcia a potential trade candidate due to his affordable contract. His recent performance trends, particularly a dip in production since mid-2023, further complicate his future with the team.

Orlando Arcia is identified as a player the Atlanta Braves could look to upgrade from, as the team may benefit from a stronger shortstop. However, the Braves typically reserve significant contracts for extending their own players, which could limit their willingness to pursue external options like Willy Adames.

Orlando Arcia started the 2023 season strong, earning his first career All-Star selection after hitting .294. However, his performance declined significantly, finishing the season with a batting average of just .218, including a league-worst .155 with a .400 OPS with runners in scoring position. This drop in offensive production has created an immediate need for the Braves at shortstop, making Hoerner an appealing target to bolster their defense and lineup.