Fantasy baseball managers often face the dilemma of underperforming pitchers who began the season with high expectations. For the 2025 drafts, several talented pitchers are projected to see a drop in their average draft position (ADP) due to disappointing 2024 seasons. These players, previously drafted for their potential, could offer significant returns for fantasy teams willing to take a chance on them.

Brandon Pfaadt from the Arizona Diamondbacks is highlighted after a challenging season marked by a 4.71 ERA, despite strong metrics indicating potential for improvement. Likewise, Bailey Ober of the Minnesota Twins showcased impressive statistics despite a 3.93 ERA. Nick Lodolo of the Cincinnati Reds, hindered by injuries, presents a bargain opportunity for 2025 drafts.

Jhoan Duran, also of the Minnesota Twins, displayed dominant underlying metrics despite a disappointing season, while Jose Leclerc is on the lookout for a new team after an inconsistent year. David Bednar from the Pittsburgh Pirates faces pressure to regain his form after a regressive season. Finally, Edwin Diaz of the New York Mets has shown signs of returning to form after a season off, suggesting he could reclaim his fantasy stardom in the upcoming year.