Will Brennan was one of the players utilized in right field for the Guardians during the 2024 season. While he showed potential as a contributor, the team experienced a rotation of players in that position, indicating a lack of consistency. With Chase DeLauter’s arrival and potential star power, Brennan's role may be challenged as the Guardians look to strengthen their lineup for future postseason runs.

Will Brennan struggled defensively in the loss to the Yankees, misplaying a double by Anthony Rizzo that allowed a run to score. Despite having a solid regular season with only two errors in 132 chances, his mistake came at a critical moment after the Guardians had narrowed the deficit. Brennan acknowledged the misplay, noting he rushed the play due to the speed of the runner, which is uncharacteristic for him.

Will Brennan committed a critical error in the sixth inning when he bobbled a ball while attempting a barehand pickup of a double, allowing a run to score. This misplay contributed to Cleveland's struggles, as they went 0 for 7 with runners in scoring position and stranded 11 runners throughout the game.

Will Brennan committed a costly error in the sixth inning when he bobbled a ball while attempting a barehand pickup of Rizzo's double, allowing a run to score. This misplay contributed to Cleveland's struggles, as the Guardians went 0 for 7 with runners in scoring position and stranded 11 runners throughout the game.

Will Brennan committed a critical error in the sixth inning when he bobbled a ball while attempting a barehand pickup of Rizzo's double, allowing a run to score. This misplay contributed to Cleveland's struggles, as the team went 0 for 7 with runners in scoring position and stranded 11 runners throughout the game.