The 2025 fantasy baseball draft season is underway, with players focusing on both early and middle rounds to build a winning roster. While big names attract attention, it’s crucial to scrutinize middle-round picks to avoid potential busts. This article highlights five pitchers that fantasy managers should steer clear of in points leagues this year due to their early average draft positions (ADP) and underlying red flags.

Emmanuel Clase, who had a stellar season with the Cleveland Guardians, is viewed as a risky pick at an ADP of 49.7, particularly because of his low strikeout rates. Jacob deGrom, despite being a two-time Cy Young winner, has struggled with injuries and lacks the innings that fantasy players need at his 56.3 ADP. Max Fried, newly signed by the New York Yankees, might be overpriced at 86.7 due to inconsistent strikeout numbers. Tyler Glasnow, known for his potential, remains a health concern at 95 ADP and may not even pitch enough to justify the pick. Lastly, Seth Lugo's low strikeout rate and decline in performance make him a questionable choice at 146.7 ADP.