The New York Mets are facing crucial decisions this offseason, particularly regarding their designated hitter position. J.D. Martinez and Jesse Winker, both on one-year contracts, contributed to the team's postseason efforts, but their futures are uncertain.

Martinez is likely to depart, while Winker, who rebounded from a tough 2023 season, demonstrated his potential in the playoffs. His strong postseason performance raises questions about his viability as a full-time player, especially given his hitting splits and past struggles.

Despite these concerns, Winker’s pedigree as a former All-Star suggests he could be a valuable asset for the Mets moving forward, making a case for his return to the team.