Iván Herrera made history for the St. Louis Cardinals by hitting three home runs in a single game against the Los Angeles Angels, marking a milestone that even legendary catchers like Yadier Molina and Ted Simmons couldn't achieve in the franchise's 123-year existence. This triumphant performance included a solo shot, a two-run homer, and a three-run blast, totaling six RBIs. Herrera’s achievement is a source of pride for him, his family, and his country, as he aims to positively represent Panama in Major League Baseball. At just 24 years old, he’s already the fifth-youngest catcher to hit three homers in a game.

Herrera's success comes after being named the Cardinals' regular catcher this season following a position change for teammate Willson Contreras, showcasing his growing confidence and skill level. Manager Oliver Marmol praised Herrera’s work ethic, indicating that his potential is limitless. With a franchise-record 12 total bases for a catcher, he is establishing himself as a key asset for the team moving forward.

In fantasy baseball, securing a top catcher is crucial due to the limited elite options available. William Contreras stands out, being the only catcher drafted in the top 50, boasting impressive stats with a .281 average, 23 homers, and 92 RBIs in 2024. Following him, Adley Rutschman, Yainer Diaz, and Cal Raleigh are popular picks, but if those are missed, several undervalued catchers are available beyond the first 90 picks.

Willson Contreras is slated as the Cardinals' primary first baseman but retains catcher eligibility, making him a smart target at an ADP of 92.3. After battling injuries in 2024, he still showcased excellent metrics, hinting he could achieve career highs if he remains healthy. Shea Langeliers, at an ADP of 127.3, recorded 29 homers last season and is a powerful option worth consideration. Logan O'Hoppe presents a high-risk but high-reward scenario, having logged 20 homers last season despite a weak second half. Gabriel Moreno offers a solid batting average, while Ivan Herrera has a chance to be a sleeper at 239.3 ADP with his batting potential.

In the realm of fantasy baseball, two-catcher leagues demand a strategic pivot as the catcher position, typically regarded as a weaker link, transforms into a critical zone of opportunity. Punting the position in single-catcher leagues often leads to streaming players from the waiver wire, but in two-catcher formats, this can leave managers at a significant disadvantage.

Assessing players ranked between 10-20, who are usually overlooked, can unveil valuable prospects. For the 2025 season, players like Ryan Jeffers of the Minnesota Twins, with a current average draft position (ADP) of 229, stands out after an impressive 2024 season where he hit 21 home runs. Similarly, Ivan Herrera of the St. Louis Cardinals, drafted at 233, showcases potential as he steps into a more prominent role after the departure of Willson Contreras. Alejandro Kirk of the Toronto Blue Jays, though disappointing in 2024, could rebound significantly with the opportunity for consistent at-bats after the trade of Danny Jansen.

The 2025 fantasy baseball season approaches and with it, an updated glimpse into catcher rankings reveals a shift in the landscape. Milwaukee Brewers' William Contreras stands out as the top choice, following an impressive season marked by 23 home runs and 99 RBIs. His rising Average Draft Position (ADP) reflects his value, especially in two-catcher leagues, where he has become a coveted asset.

St. Louis Cardinals' Ivan Herrera and New York Yankees’ Austin Wells have also made strides, demonstrating strong performances in spring training. Their batting averages and potential for production are leading them to climb the draft boards, making them players to watch.

Beyond these three, the catcher position appears more robust than in previous years, prompting fantasy managers to prioritize it—especially in leagues requiring two catchers. Regular updates will track changes across rankings, giving players the insights needed to stay ahead in their leagues.