In fantasy baseball, securing a top catcher is crucial due to the limited elite options available. William Contreras stands out, being the only catcher drafted in the top 50, boasting impressive stats with a .281 average, 23 homers, and 92 RBIs in 2024. Following him, Adley Rutschman, Yainer Diaz, and Cal Raleigh are popular picks, but if those are missed, several undervalued catchers are available beyond the first 90 picks.

Willson Contreras is slated as the Cardinals' primary first baseman but retains catcher eligibility, making him a smart target at an ADP of 92.3. After battling injuries in 2024, he still showcased excellent metrics, hinting he could achieve career highs if he remains healthy. Shea Langeliers, at an ADP of 127.3, recorded 29 homers last season and is a powerful option worth consideration. Logan O'Hoppe presents a high-risk but high-reward scenario, having logged 20 homers last season despite a weak second half. Gabriel Moreno offers a solid batting average, while Ivan Herrera has a chance to be a sleeper at 239.3 ADP with his batting potential.