Shy Tuttle received a low Pro Football Focus grade, indicating struggles in his performance. He, along with DeShawn Williams and Jonathan Harris, ranked near the bottom among the defensive starters, highlighting challenges faced by the defensive line in the game.

Shy Tuttle contributed significantly on the defensive line, showcasing his skills with impactful plays. His performance included strong run defense and the ability to disrupt the opposing offense, solidifying his role as a key player for the Panthers.

Shy Tuttle made a significant impact during the game by recovering a fumble after stripping the ball from Courtland Sutton at the 1-yard line, preventing Sutton from scoring a touchdown. This play contributed to a 98-yard touchdown drive for the Panthers, highlighting Tuttle's defensive prowess despite the team's overall struggles.

Shy Tuttle recovered a fumble late in the game, marking his second fumble recovery of the match. He played a significant role in the Panthers' defense but faced challenges as the team struggled against the Broncos. Tuttle's performance highlighted the difficulties the injury-riddled Panthers faced throughout the game.

Shy Tuttle made a significant impact by forcing a turnover on Denver's first possession, punching the ball away from Lil’Jordan Humphrey and setting the Panthers up for an early touchdown. This play underscored the struggles the Broncos faced at the start of the game, contributing to their initial deficit.