Jonathan Huberdeau's performance since joining the Calgary Flames has drawn criticism, as reflected in recent polls by The Hockey News. Despite a stellar final season with the Florida Panthers, Huberdeau has struggled to replicate that success, posting only 55 and 52 points in his first two seasons in Calgary.

In the polls, he was voted the second Most Overpaid Player in the NHL, trailing only Darnell Nurse. Additionally, Huberdeau was identified as a player whose disappointing season is seen as a reflection of his true abilities rather than a one-off fluke.