The NFL draft can often yield surprising results, especially when looking back at the biggest busts from the past five years. The list includes notable players such as Evan Neal, selected 7th overall by the New York Giants in 2022, whose performance has drawn harsh criticism for failing to bolster a struggling offensive line. Kenny Pickett, the first quarterback taken in 2022, has also faced scrutiny for his conservative play and inability to capitalize on scoring opportunities, leading to low offensive output for the Pittsburgh Steelers.

Other high-profile disappointments include Alex Leatherwood, drafted 17th overall in 2021 by the Las Vegas Raiders, who was released after just one season; and Caleb Williams, the 2024 first overall pick, whose performance has raised eyebrows despite high expectations. Quentin Johnston, Marvin Harrison Jr., Anthony Richardson, Kyle Pitts, Zach Wilson, and Trey Lance round out the list as players who have failed to meet their draft positions, with varying degrees of blame placed on team situations and personal performance.