The Pro Bowl selection process for 2025 has come under fire as only two Buffalo Bills players, quarterback Josh Allen and left tackle Dion Dawkins, were named starters despite the team's potential for 14 wins. This has led to discussions about the players who were snubbed, with cornerback Christian Benford topping the list. Benford's impressive performance this season, allowing just 0.7 yards per coverage snap, highlights his deserving candidacy for the Pro Bowl.

Running back James Cook, who leads the NFL in total touchdowns, is also seen as a strong candidate. His explosive play has been vital for the Bills' offense, and he is on the verge of tying the franchise record for rushing touchdowns. Meanwhile, right tackle Spencer Brown, despite being a fifth alternate, has received praise for his solid play and recent contract extension, reflecting his growing recognition within the team.