The Dallas Cowboys' first-round pick in 2023, defensive tackle Mazi Smith, has faced significant challenges in his rookie season. Initially seen as a necessary addition, Smith's performance has drawn criticism, particularly for his lack of impact in both run defense and pass rushing.

With a pass rush grade of 55.8 and a troubling run defense grade of 29.9, Smith's struggles have raised concerns about his future. At just 23, he still has time to improve, but he risks being labeled a bust if he cannot turn his performance around quickly.