Julian Hill faced considerable criticism from Miami Dolphins fans during the early part of the 2024 season due to repeated penalties, including four penalties in a single game against the Seattle Seahawks. These consistent infractions placed him at the top of the NFL penalty leaderboard among non-linemen, leading to frustration among the team's passionate fanbase.

However, Hill managed to significantly improve his performance in the latter half of the season, committing only one penalty over the final 11 games. This turnaround was facilitated by support from teammates like Jonnu Smith, who offered guidance and reassurance amidst the mounting pressure.

As a second-year player, Hill's role expanded, with his offensive snaps increasing substantially compared to his rookie year. He acknowledges the learning curve he experienced and is now focused on enhancing his skills, particularly in pass-catching, for the upcoming season.