The New York Giants are facing a pivotal decision regarding general manager Joe Schoen amidst a disappointing season. Despite calls for his replacement, ownership seems inclined to retain him to continue the rebuilding process.

Arguments for Schoen's retention include the need for continuity and the potential for future improvement, as seen with other franchises like the Detroit Lions. However, concerns about his player evaluations and the team's regression this season raise questions about his effectiveness.

Ultimately, while Schoen's tenure may be scrutinized, it appears unlikely that he will be dismissed this season, given the historical context of the team's management decisions.