New York Giants linebacker Dyontae Johnson's journey has been tumultuous, marked by injuries and uncertainty ahead of free agency. After an impressive offseason leading to his selection in the final roster, Johnson's 2024 season was severely hindered by an ankle injury that left him on injured reserve for most of the year. Despite the setbacks, he showcased his potential when he returned to the field, notably leading the Giants in tackles during Week 18 against the Philadelphia Eagles.

His performance, although limited, has sparked discussion on whether the Giants should retain him. With his exclusive rights free agency status, keeping Johnson would provide the team with a young, inexpensive option familiar with their defensive schemes. However, there are arguments against his retention, primarily focused on his injury history and the potential to find replacements through the draft or undrafted free agency.