Mike Tomlin's recent endorsement of Mason Rudolph as a potential starting quarterback has drawn sharp criticism from notable analysts like Shannon Sharpe. Tomlin's assertion raises questions about the Steelers’ past decision to release Rudolph if he was indeed a viable option for future success. Sharpe bluntly argues that if the Steelers had faith in Rudolph, they would not have let him go, particularly in favor of obtaining other quarterbacks like Justin Fields or Russell Wilson.

Sharpe's skepticism reflects a broader concern among commentators, who believe Tomlin should keep all options open rather than limit the conversation to Rudolph's capabilities. The Steelers' quarterback situation, as it stands, is under scrutiny, and Tomlin's confidence in Rudolph is seen as questionable in light of their past decisions and the caliber of quarterbacks available today.