Jedd Fisch, the University of Washington head coach, has expressed high praise for Tetairoa McMillan, hailing him as a "generational talent" and drawing comparisons to NFL All-Pro Mike Evans of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. As the 2025 NFL Draft nears, McMillan's stock is rising following a standout performance in 2024, where he recorded 84 receptions for 1,319 yards and eight touchdowns. Fisch notes McMillan's similar size and skill set to Evans, who has achieved 11 consecutive 1,000-yard seasons.

Fisch highlights McMillan’s impressive catch-point ability and fluidity after the catch, traits that mirror those of Evans. Despite some flaws, including an 8.7% drop rate, Fisch believes McMillan's potential is immense, and that any team drafting him can expect a decade of elite production. The Dallas Cowboys are currently favorites to select him, envisioning a potent offensive duo with CeeDee Lamb.