Rutger McGroarty scored his first professional goal during a power play, contributing to the Penguins' dominant victory. His performance, alongside fellow rookie Tristan Broz, highlighted the team's depth and offensive capabilities.

Rutger McGroarty was not included in the pipeline rankings because he is expected to play in Pittsburgh this season. However, he requires further development time in the AHL due to a lack of dynamic skill. Projected as a middle-six winger, McGroarty is known for his physical engagement and ability to make key plays at critical moments. His footwork and speed need improvement for him to reach his full potential at the NHL level.

Rutger McGroarty requested a trade from the Jets to the Penguins in hopes of securing more NHL ice time. However, after starting the season with no points in three games, he was sent to the AHL's Wilkes-Barre/Scranton. This situation amused Jets fans, especially as they watched their team dominate the Penguins in an 8-3 victory, further highlighting McGroarty's struggles to achieve his desired opportunities in Pittsburgh.

Rutger McGroarty expresses a sense of awe when in the presence of Crosby and other Hall of Fame-caliber players in the Penguins' dressing room. He recalls feeling star-struck during his first encounter and appreciates Crosby’s authenticity and the meaningfulness behind his words. McGroarty recognizes the value of learning from Crosby's leadership and demeanor, highlighting the impact that such experienced players have on younger teammates.

Rutger McGroarty stood out as a positive highlight for the Penguins in their season opener, playing on the third line alongside Jesse Puljujarvi and Lars Eller. The trio combined for eight shots and demonstrated responsible play, effectively creating chances despite the team's overall struggles. While the veteran stars failed to make an impact, McGroarty's performance suggests that he could be a valuable asset moving forward, potentially alleviating some pressure from the top two lines to generate offense.