Cristall is playing in his fourth full season with the Kelowna Rockets and has been appointed as one of the Alternate Captains. Since returning to the team on October 7, he has made a significant impact, scoring in five of the six games he played in October. He started strong with a goal and multiple assists in a 9-4 victory over the Portland Winterhawks, where he was named the First Star of the game. Cristall continued to contribute offensively, scoring key goals and assisting on others, particularly for fellow teammate Tig Iginla. By the end of October, he had tallied five goals and 11 assists for a total of 15 points, maintaining a +11 rating. The Rockets have improved their performance since his return, showing a record of 4-1-0-1.

Andrew Cristall is recognized as one of the most polarizing players in the 2024 draft class, showcasing impressive skill but facing concerns regarding his size and skating. His offensive toolbox is highly regarded, allowing him to produce at levels that defy expectations. However, his projection remains challenging; if he reaches his potential, he could become a star in the NHL, but if not, he may find success in a European league.

Andrew Cristall scored one of the goals for the Kelowna Rockets in their 7-5 victory over the Prince Albert Raiders, contributing significantly to the team's offensive efforts. His performance helped the Rockets recover from a deficit and secure the win.

Andrew Cristall has been reassigned from the NHL squad to the WHL’s Kelowna Rockets, indicating a decision by the Capitals to prioritize his development at the junior level.

Andrew Cristall has been assigned to the WHL’s Kelowna Rockets as part of the Washington Capitals' roster adjustments.