Patrick Mahomes and Justin Herbert are under scrutiny after disappointing fantasy performances over the last few seasons. However, there is optimism they may rebound in the upcoming 2025 season. Mahomes struggled with a lack of offensive weapons and injuries, finishing as the 11th quarterback in points per game in 2024, while Herbert had a slight improvement, particularly in the second half of the season, showing potential for a bounceback. The discussion also touched on other quarterbacks like Dak Prescott, who faced challenges with play-calling and injuries, and Kyler Murray, who has been hindered by inconsistency despite a strong start in previous seasons. The episode emphasized the need for improved offensive support for these players to maximize their fantasy potential.

Travis Etienne's performance raises questions as he enters a pivotal contract year, struggling with a drop in production following a promising 2023 season. The emergence of Tank Bigsby as a more reliable option complicates Etienne's fantasy outlook, with skepticism about his future in Jacksonville. A fresh start with a new team could revitalize his career.

Rhamondre Stevenson, on the other hand, faces challenges of his own after a disappointing season. With the Patriots' shaky run blocking and the return of Josh McDaniels as OC, there may be a glimmer of hope if the offensive line improves. However, his status as a reliable fantasy asset remains uncertain.

Marvin Harrison Jr.'s rookie year was less than stellar, paralleling his father’s early struggles. Despite being a high-profile talent, the lack of consistent quarterback play and separation skills hindered his progress. While comparisons to elite receivers like Jamar Chase persist, Harrison's future hinges on improvements in his game and team dynamics.

DK Metcalf’s season was marked by fewer touchdowns and a shift in the offensive scheme with a changing quarterback landscape. His reliance on big plays may not suffice in the evolving Seahawks offense, making him less of a fantasy priority next season.

Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle both faced disappointing seasons, with Hill’s production tapering off significantly from previous years. Discussions around potential team changes and adaptations in scheme could influence their fantasy value going forward.

The Fantasy Footballers Podcast hosts Andy Holloway, Jason Moore, and Mike Wright dive into the latest discussions from the football weekend, highlighting the excitement surrounding the upcoming Buffalo vs. Kansas City game. The conversation touches on the remarkable comeback game, the Chiefs' evolving image, and the growing frustration surrounding refereeing, particularly regarding flopping by players like Patrick Mahomes. The discussion shifts to the surprising performance of the Washington Commanders led by Jaden Daniels, contrasting their successes with the struggles of the Chicago Bears. The episode also critically assesses quarterbacks' performances, including Kyler Murray's inconsistencies and the rookie seasons of other quarterbacks like Brock Purdy and C.J. Stroud.

Additionally, the hosts address coaching changes across teams and their implications for player performances, like Ben Johnson joining the Bears as head coach. The segment wraps up with a focus on quarterback truths, examining the future outlook for notable players heading into the next season.

On January 15, 2025, the program humorously tackles the chaotic landscape of sports, with segments on NFL updates and player incidents. The team is situated in a snowy Indianapolis, contrasting with the warmer climates of other states, while highlighting the struggles from recent weather calamities. JJ Watt and Dan Orlovsky are slated to make guest appearances, promising to delve into current player situations, coaching dynamics, and implications for upcoming games. A significant focus includes the future of the Pittsburgh Steelers, particularly concerning Russell Wilson and the tension with offensive coordinator Ry Smith. Insights on the Ravens' offense, featuring an impressive Lamar Jackson, and the Bills' resilience bolster the conversation. The dynamics of social media, particularly TikTok's potential shutdown, are also discussed, revealing its impact on players and fans alike.

The Seahawks have concluded their season after a disappointing run, culminating in their official elimination from playoff contention. The hosts reflect on the failures of the past year, including poor coaching decisions and unfortunate game situations that led them to this point. The discussion quickly pivots to the upcoming matchup against the Los Angeles Rams, with both hosts expressing a strong desire to see the Rams falter in the playoffs, calling it a source of joy and a 'Super Bowl' of sorts for Seahawks fans. Emphasis is placed on the significance of the final game of the season, highlighted by hopes for individual player performances, including Gino Smith’s contract situation and potential roster bonuses awaiting him.

This leads to a detailed analysis of Gino Smith’s contract details, including a critical $10 million roster bonus and performance escalators that could significantly impact his future with the team. As the conversation unfolds, the hosts debate the risks of Smith’s escalating cap hit in 2025 and the potential need for the Seahawks to explore other quarterback options in the off-season. The importance of the offensive coordinator's future is also highlighted, as their decisions will likely shape Smith's role in the coming years. Ultimately, both hosts agree on the need to see how Smith performs in the season's final game, as it may influence the front office's decisions regarding his future.