The Dallas Cowboys are facing scrutiny over head coach Mike McCarthy's performance as they prepare for their Week 16 game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Despite winning three of their last four games, McCarthy has struggled to elevate the team beyond the divisional round of the playoffs, mirroring the failures of his predecessor, Jason Garrett.

Critics argue that McCarthy's coaching strategies have been ineffective, particularly in high-stakes games, and that his reliance on star players like Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb has overshadowed his lack of innovative offensive schemes. The Cowboys' offensive struggles, especially during crucial moments, raise questions about McCarthy's ability to manage the team effectively.

While the Cowboys have shown some fight this season, many believe that simply being competitive is not enough. The organization should consider exploring new coaching options that could provide a greater advantage in preparation and strategy, rather than settling for mere relevance under McCarthy.