The Indianapolis Colts have long adhered to a strategy of drafting and developing their own players, resulting in both successes and setbacks. Recent extensions of key players like Quenton Nelson and Jonathan Taylor show the team’s commitment to maintaining a core group. However, with many young players facing contract decisions in the coming years, particularly ahead of 2025, the Colts must navigate potential extensions for several promising talents.

Among these, safety Nick Cross, who emerged as a starter in 2024, had an impressive season with 146 tackles and three interceptions, making him a prime candidate for an extension. Kwity Paye, while not yet an elite pass rusher, has shown steady improvement, and Alec Pierce proved his value with a breakout year. Lastly, Bernhard Raimann's consistent performance has positioned him as a key offensive tackle. As the Colts look to solidify their roster, careful contract management will be crucial.