Nick Cross finished second among safeties in total tackles, showcasing his ability to rack up numbers. However, he ranked fourth in tackles versus expected, largely due to a high expected tackle total of 112.1, attributed to playing a significant portion of his snaps in the box. With the recent firing of Gus Bradley, there are concerns about Cross's potential regression in 2025.

Nick Cross emerged as a promising starter at safety, showcasing significant improvement during the season. His rise in production coincided with increased competition within the roster, highlighting the positive impact of fostering a competitive environment. Ballard's acknowledgment of Cross's development indicates a recognition of the need for effective player acquisition and the importance of competition in enhancing overall team performance.

Nick Cross faced skepticism entering the 2024 season but proved his worth as the most talented safety on the team. He excelled in run-stopping, achieving a PFF grade of 80.4, and set career highs in tackles, passes defended, sacks, and interceptions. His performance has instilled confidence in the Colts' coaching staff about his potential as a starting safety for the future.

Nick Cross was unable to stop Malik Nabers during a critical play, as he failed to tackle the rookie wide receiver on a screen pass that resulted in a 31-yard touchdown. This moment highlighted the challenges the Colts' defense faced against the Giants' emerging playmakers.

Nick Cross has made significant strides in his development, transforming from a player who struggled to see the field into a key contributor for the Colts. In 2024, he has emerged as a standout safety, currently ranking second among NFL defensive backs with 126 tackles, along with three interceptions and a forced fumble. His impressive performance in his first full season as a starter has positioned him as a potential Pro Bowl selection.