Matt Gay was instrumental in the Colts' victory, scoring the game-winning 38-yard field goal in overtime. He contributed significantly throughout the game, adding two more field goals in the first half, helping the Colts to a 20-13 halftime lead. His performance capped off a season where he showcased reliability as a kicker.

Matt Gay struggled in the game against the Giants, missing a critical 54-yard field goal that contributed to ongoing concerns about his performance on long attempts. With a season record of 3/8 from 50+ yards, his inconsistency has become a narrative surrounding him, despite being a solid kicker overall. The Colts need him to improve in this area moving forward, especially as they look to finish the season on a high note.

Matt Gay's performance has been a point of concern for the Colts, highlighted by a missed field goal that contributed to the team's struggles. As the Colts face mounting pressure to regain momentum, his kicking consistency will be crucial in their efforts to stay competitive and keep playoff hopes alive.

Matt Gay has been a reliable kicker for the Colts, though he recently missed a 55-yard field goal against the Titans, marking his first miss since Week 9. His performance has improved compared to last season, making it unlikely the team will consider replacing him this late in the year.

Matt Gay converted 5-of-5 extra points and was 1-of-2 on field goals, maintaining a 50% success rate in the game. His performance contributed to the Colts' scoring efforts, showcasing his reliability as a kicker.