Gardner Minshew was signed to a two-year, $25 million contract as part of the Raiders' quarterback strategy for the 2024 season. However, his addition has been criticized as the team's overall quarterback plan was deemed subpar, especially after Telesco's failure to draft a quarterback in the first round due to an unexpected run on the position.

Minshew's season was marred by injuries and ineffectiveness, ultimately leading to his placement on injured reserve after suffering a broken collarbone. His struggles contributed to the team's overall disappointing performance, as he was unable to provide the stability needed at the quarterback position during a tumultuous year for the Raiders.

Gardner Minshew started the season as the Raiders' quarterback after signing a two-year deal but struggled to maintain consistency. He was benched for Aidan O'Connell mid-season, only to return to the starting role after O'Connell's injury. This instability at the quarterback position was a significant factor in the team's poor performance and ultimately contributed to Antonio Pierce's firing.

Gardner Minshew was signed by the Raiders to a two-year, $25 million contract with $15 million guaranteed, following an offseason where the team struggled to trade up for a quarterback in the draft. Minshew initially won a competitive training camp battle against second-year player Aidan O'Connell but faced challenges as the season progressed. His performance did not meet expectations, leading to his benching after five games. The Raiders' offense, under new offensive coordinator Luke Getsy, failed to start strong, contributing to the team's overall struggles.

Gardner Minshew's performance under Antonio Pierce was hampered by a lack of consistency at quarterback. The Raiders struggled offensively, with Minshew and others failing to provide the stability needed, which contributed to the team's disappointing 4-13 record. Pierce's indecision regarding the starting quarterback further complicated the situation, as the offense never fully matched the defensive intensity.