The Miami Dolphins are struggling with a 2-6 record, leading to a harsh midseason report card. General manager Chris Grier and coach Mike McDaniel are criticized for their offseason decisions, particularly regarding backup quarterbacks. Tua Tagovailoa's performance has been below average, and the running game has been inconsistent despite some strong individual performances.

The offensive line has exceeded expectations, while the defensive line has suffered from injuries. The coaching staff, particularly McDaniel, faces scrutiny for undisciplined play and failure to utilize star players effectively. Overall, the season has been disappointing, with significant room for improvement.