The 2024 NFL draft class has made its mark, with high expectations leading to a mix of impressive performances and disappointing debuts. Caleb Williams, the first overall pick for the Chicago Bears, faced challenges behind a struggling offensive line, suffering 68 sacks while showing flashes of potential amidst concerns over accuracy and decision-making. Jonathon Brooks of the Carolina Panthers encountered injury setbacks in his rookie season, limiting his impact as Chuba Hubbard stepped up in his absence. Trey Benson found limited opportunities with the Arizona Cardinals, while Malachi Corley of the New York Jets struggled to rise in a crowded receiver group that added Davante Adams.

Marvin Harrison Jr. had a respectable start with 885 yards and eight touchdowns for the Cardinals, but his performance was overshadowed by other rookies who exceeded expectations. Adonai Mitchell's prospects remain uncertain as he could not secure a prominent role on the Colts. Blake Corum failed to make an impression with the Rams, rarely seeing the field, while Jermaine Burton faced off-field issues impacting his playing time with the Bengals. At the top of the list, Ja'Lynn Polk, selected 37th overall by the Patriots, had a notably underwhelming rookie campaign, raising questions about his future on the team.