The Indianapolis Colts are confronted with tough decisions regarding in-house free agents for the 2025 season, particularly concerning veteran center Ryan Kelly. At 31, Kelly has experienced a notable decline marked by injuries that limited him to just 10 games in 2024. There are indications he is open to leaving the Colts, despite his desire to stay. Rookie Tanor Bortolini impressed while filling in for Kelly, posting respectable blocking stats, although Kelly's metrics still outperform his due to experience. With the question of Kelly's potential contract renewal looming, his age and injury history make the Colts hesitant to invest significantly. The Colts must prioritize securing their offensive line to support young quarterback Anthony Richardson and coach Shane Steichen's offensive strategy.